Is this a Ruddy Duck x White-headed Duck hybrid?

By | 20 January 2013

Abdelhak Elbanak photographed this stiff-tailed duck earlier this month at the lake of Sidi Boughaba which he originally identified as a Ruddy Duck (Oxyura jamaicensis). But upon looking at the photo more closely, I think it could be a Ruddy Duck x White-headed Duck hybrid. This bird has different characteristics that can be found in one species or the other and here I list the most important:

  • Bill is relatively large with slightly swollen culmen at the base, this must have been inherited from a White-headed Duck (Oxyura leucocephala) parent. The bill of Ruddy Duck is much thinner and not swollen.
  • Head is almost all white except a narrow black area on the crown, the white is so extensive that reaches the neck, this also must have been inherited from a White-headed Duck parent (in Ruddy Duck, the white is not very extensive while the black on the head is very extensive in all plumages and extends to the neck and eyes).
  • Body colour (bright chestnut) must have been inherited from a Ruddy Duck parent.
  • White undertail coverts also inherited from a Ruddy Duck parent.

The question is: what are the parents of this bird? What do you think? Comments welcome. Thanks.

It should be noted that hybridisation between these two Oxyura species happened in Europe, and some hybrids were already recorded in Morocco as well in the past. The hybridisation may cause conservation concerns for the growing population of the White-headed Duck in Morocco if went unchecked. In recent years, it’s not uncommon to see tens or hundreds White headed Ducks all year round at some sites like Sidi Boughaba and Douyet. Some of these birds are wintering but many are breeding birds.

Update: it’s a White-headed Duck

After seeing more photographs, Carlos Gutiérrez Expósito who is as expert in the identification and control of Ruddy Duck in Spain commented the following (see also the comments section below):

Dear friends, thanks for the photos. Definitely and fortunately, the shot belongs to an adult male White-headed Duck. There is no sign of hybridisation and all plumage and bare parts features match perfect with Oxyura leucocephala. White-headed Ducks have two colour morphs. One pale and another one dark. In this case you have one pale bird, because of this it has pale undertail coverts, but not pure white as you find in Ruddy Duck and hybrids. Body shape, body colour (chestnut, not reddish), very white head and blue swollen bill, all match with White-headed Duck. And if you get a detailed view of the bill base, you will see that the profile of the bill base (limit with plumed face) is inverted S shaped. This feature is always like an inverted C in Ruddy Ducks, and mixed in hybrids.

I’m very happy to see that you are in alert with this very serious conservation problem
for the western population of White-headed Duck.

All the best,

 

Thanks Carlos for your comments and thanks also to Benoît Maire, Jacques Franchimont and Diego Jeréz for their comments as well.

White-headed Duck (Oxyura leucocephala) mistaken for Ruddy Duck (Oxyura jamaicensis) and hybrid of both species.

White-headed Duck (Oxyura leucocephala) mistaken for Ruddy Duck (Oxyura jamaicensis) and hybrid of both species, Sidi Boughaba, January 2013 (Abdelhak Elbanak).

3 thoughts on “Is this a Ruddy Duck x White-headed Duck hybrid?

  1. Carlos Gutiérrez Expósito

    Dear Mohamed, I'm happy to see photos from our friend Abdelhak. As expert in identification and Ruddy Duck control in Spain, to me, fortunately this seems more like a pure male White-headed Duck. I'll would be very grateful if you can send me the photograph to analyse it in detail. A couple of years ago I visited this lake, and I was very happy to see more tha 80 white-headed Ducks with any signal of hybridisation with Ruddy Duck. Thanks to the well done work made in Great Britain. Carlos Gutiérrez

    Reply
  2. Abdelhak Elbanak

    Thanks Mohamed and Carlos . I want add that this years in my last visit to the lake of Sidi Boughaba with Imad Cherkaoui and Adel Bouajaja saw more than 240 White-headed Ducks. I will send you some pictures of this bird to clarify if this is Ruddy Duck or not ! Thanks

    Reply
  3. magornitho Post author

    Thanks Carlos for your comment. I think this is a very interesting individual, it has a combination of characteristics that I've never seen (neither in bird guides nor in nature): white head, white undertail coverts and dark colour of the body. Learned something new from this bird. Waiting Abdelhak’s photos.

    Thanks all.
    Mohamed

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *